How to get back into your church website when nobody has the login
The person who built your church's website moved away, changed churches or just stopped answering. Here's how to find out what you own and get the keys back, in the order that wastes the least time.
14-day free trialNo credit cardCancel anytimeKeep everything you build.
Find out who holds your domain with a free ICANN Lookup, then contact that company's support as the church, with proof you represent it. Do the same for wherever the site itself is built, and once you're back in, put both logins in a church account more than one person can reach. Promptly helps with the domain step when you move: it detects where your domain is managed and shows the exact steps for that provider.
Get your church's website back
Steps checked
Ask the person first, kindly
Before anything formal, reach out to whoever built the site. Most volunteers are glad to help and just forgot they were holding the keys. Ask for three things: where the domain is registered, where the website is built or hosted, and the email address on each account.
If they still have access, have them add a church email to each account instead of handing over their password.
Look up who holds your domain
Go to ICANN Lookup and enter your church's domain, like gracechurch.org. The result names the registrar, the company your domain is registered with, and shows when the registration expires.
Write down the expiration date. If it's close, getting access just became the most urgent item on the list.
Find any renewal emails
Search the church office inbox and any shared church email for the registrar's name and words like renewal or invoice. Renewal notices go to the email on the account, so finding one tells you which address you need to recover.
Check the church's card statements too. A yearly charge from a registrar or website company confirms who's been paying and when.
Recover the domain account as the church
If you can get into the email on the account, use the registrar's normal password reset. If you can't, contact the registrar's support and explain that the domain belongs to the church and the person who set it up is gone.
Expect them to ask for proof. Have church letterhead, your EIN or other official church documents, and a statement from a church leader ready before you call.
Do the same for where the site is built
The domain and the website are often two different accounts. The site might live on a website builder, a WordPress host or a designer's account. Look at the site's footer and any old invoices to see which, then go through that company's account recovery the same way.
Put the logins where the church can always reach them
Once you're in, change each account's email to a church address that more than one person can open, like office@ or admin@, not a staff member's personal email. Turn on two-step sign-in, and store the logins in a password manager the church controls.
Then write a one-page note for whoever comes next: what the domain is, where it's registered, where the site is built, when each renews and who has access.
Why the domain comes before the website
Your domain is the address on your sign, your bulletins and every link people have saved. If it expires and someone else registers it, getting it back can be hard or impossible. A website you can rebuild. The address is harder to replace.
That's why the expiration date from your lookup decides your order of work. If the domain renews soon, start there, and ask the registrar whether they can renew it for you while you prove ownership.
When the site can't be recovered
Sometimes the website account is truly gone: an old free plan, a designer who closed shop, or a host that won't help. As long as you control the domain, that's a setback, not a disaster. You can build a new site and point your existing domain at it, and the address people know keeps working.
Save what you can first. Copy the text from your current pages, download the photos you want to keep, and note your service times, ministries and staff names. That gives you a head start on the new site.
If your new site is built with Promptly
Promptly builds a new church site from a conversation about your church, and gives it a free address while you work on it. When you're ready to go live on your own domain, Promptly detects where your domain is managed and shows the exact steps for that provider.
Set up the Promptly account with a church email, not a personal one. Changes happen by typing a request, so the site no longer depends on one volunteer's skills.
Checked against: ICANN Lookup. Other companies change their menus, so use their help pages if a step looks different.
Common questions
Who owns our church's domain if a volunteer registered it?
Usually the person or email listed on the registrar account controls it, whoever paid. That's why it matters to get the account moved to a church email before someone leaves.
How do I find out where our church website is hosted?
Look at the site's footer, old invoices and renewal emails. ICANN Lookup tells you the domain's registrar, which is often, but not always, the same company that hosts the site.
What if our domain already expired?
Contact the registrar right away. Many registrars hold an expired domain for a while before releasing it, and the original owner can often renew it during that time. The length varies by registrar.
Should we keep our old domain or get a new one?
Keep the old one if you can get it back. It's on your sign and in people's bookmarks, and changing it means updating everything that points to it.
Keep reading
- Custom domainYour church gets a free yourchurch.promptly.church address the day you start. When you subscribe, connect the domain your church already owns.
- Replace an old siteBuild your new site with Promptly while your old one keeps running. When the new one is ready, point your domain and make the switch.
- Livestream on your websiteYour stream already goes to YouTube, Facebook or Vimeo. Here's how to show it on your church's own site, so people watch next to your Plan Your Visit page and not a feed of someone else's videos.
- PricingOne plan with everything included. $49 a month billed yearly.
Your church website is one conversation away.
Start a conversation with Promptly and walk away with a website built around your voice, your colors and your story.
14-day free trialNo credit cardCancel anytimeKeep everything you build.
