Promptly vs Squarespace: which fits your church?
Squarespace makes beautiful sites for any kind of business. Promptly builds church sites from a conversation and keeps them current when you ask.
14-day free trialNo credit cardCancel anytimeKeep everything you build.
Squarespace is the better pick if you have a design-minded volunteer who wants a polished site and will add giving and sermons separately. Promptly is the better pick if you want your church site designed and written for you in one conversation, then updated by typing what you need in plain words.
Promptly and Squarespace, side by side
| What you’re comparing | Promptly | Squarespace |
|---|---|---|
| How the site gets built | You answer questions about your church in a chat. Promptly designs the site and writes every page. | Blueprint AI asks about your goals, personality, pages, colors and fonts, then outputs a draft with starter copy and images. |
| Who writes the pages | Promptly writes Home, About, Connect, Events, Watch, Give and Plan Your Visit from your answers. No placeholder text. | Blueprint AI gives you starter copy. You write and finish every page. |
| Making changes later | Type a request to Ask Promptly, like "Change our Sunday service time to 10:30 AM." It makes the edit and the change is live right away. Manual editing is there too. | You edit by hand in the Fluid Engine editor. AI credits are limited per plan. |
| Design | Six example styles, from warm and welcoming to modern and minimal. Promptly designs around your church's name, colors, photos and words. | Polished designs and a clean editor with fine control over layout. |
| Sermons and livestream | Connect YouTube to import recent sermons, or add them by hand. The Watch page shows your live stream during service, then switches back to the sermon archive. | Audio and video blocks for sermons. No sermon manager. |
| Giving | Your Give page and Give buttons link to the giving service your church already uses. Promptly doesn't process donations. | No built-in giving. You embed a provider like Donorbox. |
| Price | $49/mo billed yearly, or $59/mo monthly. Everything included. | Basic $19/mo billed yearly ($25 monthly). Core $29/mo yearly ($39 monthly). Plus $49 ($65). Advanced $99 ($139). Free domain for a year on annual plans. |
| Free trial | 14 days free, every feature on, no credit card. | 14-day free trial, no card. |
| Contracts | No contracts, no cancellation fees, cancel any time. | Cancel any time. |
Squarespace details checked November 2026 from Squarespace pricing page. Prices change, so confirm with Squarespace before you decide.
Which one fits your church
Choose Squarespace if
- You want polished, design-forward layouts and fine control over every block.
- You have a volunteer who enjoys writing and maintaining pages by hand.
- You want a lower entry price. Basic is $19/mo billed yearly.
- You'd use the free year of Google Workspace that comes with Core.
Choose Promptly if
- You want church pages written for you, including Plan Your Visit, Watch and Give.
- You want sermons imported from YouTube and a Watch page that shows your live stream.
- You want to update the site by typing a request, with no editor to learn.
- You want one plan with everything included.
Blueprint AI drafts it, then the editor is yours
Squarespace Blueprint AI asks about your goals, personality, pages, colors and fonts, then hands you a draft with starter copy and images. From there you edit by hand in the Fluid Engine editor, and AI credits are limited by plan. Squarespace isn't built for churches, so the draft is a general website you shape into a church site.
Promptly's questions are about church life: service times, what visitors should expect, your ministries, how people give. It designs the site around your name, colors, photos and words and writes Home, About, Connect, Events, Watch, Give and Plan Your Visit. After launch, the same kind of chat keeps working. You type a change to Ask Promptly and it's live right away.
Polished design, with church features added from elsewhere
Squarespace's designs are polished and its editor is clean. Hosting, SSL and SEO basics are included. For a church that cares most about looks and has someone with a good eye, that's a real advantage.
The church pieces take assembly. Squarespace has audio and video blocks for sermons but no sermon manager. There's no built-in giving, so you embed a provider like Donorbox, and there's no church event registration.
Promptly imports recent sermons from your connected YouTube channel, or you add them by hand with title, speaker and scripture reference. Its Watch page shows your live stream during service. Giving links out to your provider, since Promptly doesn't process donations either.
Who keeps the site current
With Squarespace, you write every page and maintain it by hand. That suits a volunteer who likes the work. It gets harder when that volunteer moves on and the service times on the homepage stop matching Sunday.
Promptly is built for the pastor or admin who'd rather type "Add a church potluck on November 16 at 6 PM in the fellowship hall" and get back to ministry. Ask Promptly makes the edit and says what it did. Manual editing is there for anyone who prefers it.
Price, trial and commitment
Squarespace Basic is $19/mo billed yearly or $25 monthly. Core is $29/mo yearly or $39 monthly and adds unlimited contributors and more video. Annual plans include a free domain for a year. Both Squarespace and Promptly offer a 14-day free trial without a card.
Promptly is $49/mo billed yearly or $59/mo monthly, everything included. Your own domain connects on a paid plan, and Promptly detects where it's managed and shows the exact steps. Neither has a contract, and you can cancel either any time.
Common questions
Does Squarespace have an AI website builder?
Yes. Squarespace Blueprint AI asks about your goals, pages, colors and fonts and outputs a draft with starter copy and images. You then edit by hand in the Fluid Engine editor.
Can Squarespace take church donations?
Not on its own. Squarespace has no built-in giving, so churches embed a provider like Donorbox. Promptly also links to your giving provider and doesn't process donations.
Is Squarespace cheaper than Promptly?
Squarespace Basic is $19/mo billed yearly and Core is $29/mo billed yearly, so the entry price is lower. Promptly is $49/mo billed yearly with the writing, design and every feature included.
Can I add sermons to a Squarespace church site?
Yes, with audio and video blocks, but there's no sermon manager. Promptly imports recent sermons from your YouTube channel and lets you add others by hand.
Keep reading
- Squarespace alternativesSquarespace makes polished sites, but giving and sermons come from somewhere else and every page is yours to write. These options cost less, give you more control, or take the writing off your plate.
- vs WixWix and Promptly can both build a site from a description. Wix is built for every kind of business, and Promptly is built around church pages.
- Sermons & livestreamConnect your YouTube channel and Promptly brings in your recent sermons. On Sunday, the same Watch page can show your live stream.
- PricingOne plan with everything included. $49 a month billed yearly.
Your church website is one conversation away.
Start a conversation with Promptly and walk away with a website built around your voice, your colors and your story.
14-day free trialNo credit cardCancel anytimeKeep everything you build.
